Welcome to new subscribers! Anyone who can be in D.C. on Tuesday:

If you’re not in D.C. or can’t make it to the Capitol, tell everyone you know to call their senators to stop BAAJA.

The lame-duck Senate leaders John Thune (R-S.D.) and Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) are hastening the nation towards catastrophe, with the second vote to limit debate on the democracy- and planet-threatening BAAJA bill coming this afternoon, and the third debate-limiting vote 30 hours later.

BAAJA (the “Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act”) will speed up the construction of fossil-fueled data centers everywhere, which is why the American Petroleum Institute and the White House Energy Dominance Council backs this deal.

It effectively repeals the National Environmental Policy Act, the National Historic Preservation Act, and the Environmental Species Act, and cripples the Clean Water Act and potentially more of the administrative state, unleashing Donald Trump’s golf courses and gulags and Elon Musk’s data centers and spaceports. Its new project-certainty rules and repeals of bedrock laws put corporations and the Trump administration above the law, threatening American democracy. Its heavy costs will come without benefits, as careful analysis of the 494-page text has uncovered that its proponents’ pledges are false promises.

❝

At an incredibly precarious juncture for the AI market, BAAJA functions as a “backdoor bailout”: enacting legal changes that will speed up and expand access to the industry’s biggest constraint—power—despite unacceptable costs to our economy, democracy, and environment. BAAJA helps AI companies double down on their speculative bets.

From Chaco Canyon to the Arctic Refuge, to landmarks in the nation’s capital, BAAJA would make the Trump administration’s drilling, mining, and development approvals nearly impossible to undo.

The Center for Western Priorities has constructed a map of some of the public lands under immediate threat from BAAJA, from Bears Ears and Mount Taylor to Oak Flat and the Boundary Waters. BAAJA will allow the immediate construction of uranium mines, oil and gas drilling, logging, pipelines, hyperscalers—and the destruction of historic places, which is Trump’s personal priority. As CWP writes:

❝

Preservationists and local golfers have sued over Trump’s plans to remake the historic East Potomac Golf Course, and the District of Columbia and Virginia have sued to block construction of Trump’s “triumphal arch” near Arlington National Cemetery, citing violations of the National Environmental Policy Act, the National Historic Preservation Act, and other laws.

BAAJA could gut those challenges. The bill’s most consequential provision for Trump’s Washington projects is its limit on what judges can do while lawsuits play out. Under Sections 1110 and 2301, courts generally couldn’t cancel an approval or halt construction over violations of NEPA or the NHPA, the two laws most relevant to projects like these. The judge could only send the decision back for more study while demolition or construction moved forward. Once the Park Service finished its new review, it could simply approve the same plan again, even if the review showed serious harm to the city’s historic landscape.

The fight over the East Potomac Golf Course illustrates what that would mean. Trump wants to turn the public course into a venue for major championships like the U.S. Open, and in October crews cut down at least 400 trees there over a holiday weekend with little notice to the court. The DC Preservation League and two local golfers sued, and U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes found that officials had rushed the tree-cutting plan to meet Trump’s demands for speed. She ordered the work halted, then extended that order into a preliminary injunction barring further tree removal and requiring notice before any permanent changes to the course while the case proceeds. Because the plaintiffs’ case rests on claims that the administration tried to bypass NEPA, an injunction like that likely wouldn’t be possible under BAAJA.

East Potomac's Miniature Golf Course listed in the National Register of Historic Places

On Saturday, I took my family down to Hains Point to enjoy East Potomac Park before BAAJA’s potential passage. We enjoyed the historic miniature golf course, a unique gem that has been recently restored to pristine condition.

On Sunday, I joined a rally to celebrate Judge Reyes’s injunction and issued the call to action against BAAJA. For many of these activists, including lead plaintiffs in the suit to protect the public golf course from Trump, this was the first they had learned about the bill and its existential threat to Hains Point.

Third Act DMV’s John MacDonald at the Hains Point rally celebrating the temporary restraining order of the closure of East Potomac Park, Sunday, November 15, 2026.

The national legal community is trying to drill some sense into our senators.

Eighteen state attorneys general have written to the Senate calling for more deliberation; 14 of their senators, including Schumer and co-sponsor Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.), have supported fast-tracking the bill.

99 legal scholars and counting have signed a letter to the Senate identifying twelve distinct dangers of the bill and calling for more deliberation:

❝

The bill is now on the Senate floor, and final passage will require 60 votes. We urge you to offer and support floor amendments that eliminate the twelve problems identified above, beginning with Sections 1401 and 1402, the NEPA remedy and judicial review provisions, and the historic preservation title. If those amendments fail, vote no on cloture and on final passage. At a minimum, support returning the bill to committee for hearings and genuine consultation with Tribal Nations and affected communities.

Former D.C. Circuit Judge David Tatel, whose Massachusetts v. EPA opinion on greenhouse pollution was affirmed by the Supreme Court, noted that BAAJA likely will allow Trump’s golf courses and gulags to go forward.

❝

Just last month, a federal judge relied on NEPA to stop the current administration as it bulldozed hundreds of trees at the East Potomac Golf Course. Earlier this year, a federal judge in Maryland halted the conversion of a warehouse in Maryland into an ICE detention center because it violated NEPA. Neither result is likely to be repeated if the permitting bill becomes law.

Tatel calls for the Senate to take a “hard look” at this legislation instead its rush to passage. “I, for one, continue to believe in the value of looking before we leap. It seems the best way to ensure we like where we land.”

“Congress should press pause on BAAJA,” agrees prominent Supreme Court scholar Steve Vladeck. The radical bill “curbs courts, empowers the executive, and has thus far received a woefully inadequate legislative process. It warrants much more care and deliberation before passage.”

❝

BAAJA’s good parts are reason enough to get the rest of it right; its bad parts should worry you whatever your views on environmental policy; and a rushed, lame-duck vote after a decidedly bereft legislative process is a lousy way to decide whether the pros outweigh the cons. Whatever the right answers are, they demand far more deliberation than they’ve received so far—and at this late date, only the next Congress can provide it.

BAAJA Senate Vote Tracker

Monday, November 16

Tuesday, November 17

Wednesday, November 18

If BAAJA clears the Senate, House passage is possible by the end of the week. Now is the time for action.

a moment of play

Hill Heat’s U.S. Climate Politics Almanac is made available to the public thanks to our paid subscribers. Join their ranks today and grow the movement:

Reply

Avatar

or to participate